Bagels scared me. I saw all these people instagramming photos of their gorgeous bagels and I would think: how the heck did they do that? or, I can’t possibly make bagels like that, right? or, wow, that must have taken forever, I don’t have time for that. Wrong. Bagels are not as hard as you think. Highly recommending giving bagels a try!
Quick project summary: To make bagels, I used the Sally’s Baking Addiction Recipe at the recommendation of a family member. There are options for plain, everything, etc on her site but the basics are the same. So far, I have made everything and plain and I actually made no modifications to this recipe. Ok, well, maybe some: I got a bit lazy with the everything bagel and just used an everything bagel spice mix instead of actually making my own. Oops!
Despite making no modifications, here are a few recommendations I learned along the way:
-The dough will be very thick/stiff. This meant that shaping the bagels was a lot harder for me the first time than I anticipated (or than Sally’s recipe describes). Overall, my recommendation is to take the dough and really fold it over itself/work it until you get a smooth texture on the top of the bagels. I was a bit worried this would deflate the bagels but it didn’t.
-The water bath process stressed me out the first time. Between flipping the bagels in the water bath and timing them, I felt like I was on my own personal episode of chopped. I realized after making these a couple times that the timing for the water bath did not need to be exact – whew! This brought a lot of relief and resulted in a lot less bagel flipping stress.
-Know that the bagels will still look pretty tiny before the water bath. I was surprised at how much they puffed in both the water bath and the oven! At first, I thought I may have accidentally made bagel bites when I first shaped them but they puff much more than you might expect.
-For scooping the bagels out of the bath, they need to go on the baking sheet where you plan to bake them. They get a bit sticky and you won’t want to move them after putting them down once. The first time I made them, I used a spatula to scoop them out of the bath and they were a little more wet when I placed them on the baking sheet than I’d hoped. I’d recommend a tool like this which was gifted to me by a bagel baking angel – it’s a lifesaver.
Things I loved about this project: Everything (bagels). The bagel making process was fun and interactive. I loved that it was different than anything I’d ever done before with the water bath situation. And, I was so shocked that these tasted like “real” store bought bagels – delicious! Plus, I conquered one of my baking fears! Maybe donuts are next?
What I would do differently: As mentioned above, I’d definitely be a bit more aggressive with my bagel shaping. Round 1 of bagel making for me consisted of 4 decent looking bagels and 4 pretty ugly/split bagels (don’t worry, we still ate them!). By round 2, I was much more confident in my bagel shaping and all 8 bagels looked pretty normal!
Things I also enjoyed while doing this project:
-Burning my “joy and laughter” candle from Target
-Eating whipped Philadelphia cream cheese on my freshly made bagels (Seriously, I didn’t know whipped cream cheese was a thing until very recently but it’s delish!).